As I finish my fourth week of teaching, I think it's about time that I explain my job here in China. All Yale-China Teaching Fellows teach English classes for two years at four different sites in China: Hong Kong, Changsha (Hunan Province), Anhui Province, and Guangzhou. The lifestyle, physical environment, and teaching requirements vary dramatically between the different sites. Anhui is a high-school in rural China; Changsha is the capital of Hunan province and fellows either teach at Hunan University or Yali High school; Hong Kong fellows teach at the Chinese University of Hong Kong; Guangzhou fellows teach at Lingnan (University) College at Sun Yat Sen University (Zhongshan DaXue, ZhongDa for short). Teaching hours range from 8 to 12 hours per week, not including preparation and grading. The schedule is designed to give fellows ample opportunities to study Chinese, explore their sites, and volunteer/get involved in student activities. Also "english" classes mean something different in each site, depending on the level of the students. Fellows can teach anything from oral English to Shakespeare; often fellows have great freedom in designing both their syllabus and individual lesson plans. Overall, I think most of the fellows have been quite impressed by their students' English levels.
At ZhongDa, this is the first year that there are four fellows at Lingnan (University) College, the prestigious business school. Last year, two fellows taught at Lingnan and two taught at the School of Humanities; both schools are on the same campus but have different students.As a result of the change, each semester two of the fellows teach primarily at ZhongDa's Guangzhou campus and the other two teach at ZhongDa's Zhuhai campus, a 2-hour bus ride away. A coastal city, Zhuhai is supposed to be beautiful but rather boring. Students study there for their first and second years before moving to the main campus in Guangzhou. This semester, Peter and Celia are teaching four classes each at Zhuhai and one seminar in Guangzhou. Their Zhuhai classes are about persuasive speaking and writing, while the Guangzhou seminar is about the U.S. Constitution. Hanna and I teach two courses, of two sections each, in Guangzhou as well as weekly faculty and staff classes. Each section meets for 40 minutes and the faculty and staff classes are an hour and a half each on Tuesday and Thursday evenings. We also hold office hours for an hour and a half a week and host an English table lunch on Tuesdays. Next semester, she and I will travel to Zhuhai each week, spend a night there, and Celia and Peter will take over the faculty and staff classes. The Zhuhai situation is not ideal, because it decreases our time in Guangzhou and doesn't allow much interaction outside the classroom with the students there, but we're hoping that improvements can be made each semester.
We have complete freedom in the courses we teach here, which is both exciting and overwhelming. We were only told to teach an "English" class, where improving English skills would be a priority, and a "Content" class. So, Hanna and I had the rather daunting task of designing two separate courses for our undergraduates--in just a few days time and with limited access to English books or other printed materials (thank goodness for the internet!). Fortunately, the U.S. Presidential election generated enough material and interest out of which to create two classes. Our English class is entitled "Obama vs. McCain: English Skills through the Study of Campaign 2008." After having a week of introductions and a week of learning about the American political system (try teaching an overview of the US government in 40 minutes!), we've focused on how the candidates present themselves to the American people and the images they create. We've looked at the candidates' websites and studied the slogans they use (and had a vocabulary quiz); we've read emails from each candidate to their list serve; we've read excerpts of their biographies. The students have also given 5 minute "hot issue" presentations in pairs on important topics in the election and U.S. in general: they got to choose among healthcare, education, abortion, gay rights, the environment/energy crisis, the economy, foreign policy and trade, the war in Iraq, terrorism, and immigration. This coming week we'll be doing a short unit on speeches, where we watch a few minutes of McCain and Obama's speeches to prospective voters and then have an impromtu speaking activity. The students will choose a topic related to the presentations or politics in general ("the role of the president"), and have a minute to prepare a two minute speech. We'll see how it goes! Then they will be working in groups and individually on their midterm assignments, which will be to create their own political parties and candidates, decide positions on the issues and then write a biography, emails or a speech (choose 2/3). We're trying to choose creative assignments to challenge them beyond the rote memorization that they are used to (and good at). In November, we'll be doing some analysis of the election and backtracking a bit to a debate unit. We'll end the course with a unit on the media's role in politics, different news sources, and humor/parody in politics. We're still not sure what their final examination will be, so any ideas are welcome!
Our "Content" class is entitled "The American Stage, Then and Now: Influential American Leaders and the Speeches that Changed U.S. History." The syllabus has three units--African American Orators, Wartime President Orators, and Women Orators--and we're almost done with the first unit. The aim of the class is to study the historical context, the orators and their speeches, and the movements and efforts that brought us to this historic election. Hanna and I both want our students to realize how unique this election is--the first African American nominee, two ongoing wars, a woman who was very nearly nominated (and another as a vice presidential candidate)--and see the history that preceded and helped bring it about. We are reading two speeches per unit (even though we could read many more, Hanna and I thought it would be too rushed and superficial): Frederick Douglass' "What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?", Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I have a Dream", Franklin Delano Roosevelt's "Four Freedoms", Abraham Lincoln's "Gettysburg Address", and Sojourner Truth's "Ain't I a Woman?" We still have to decide on the other speech by a female orator, perhaps something by Alice Paul. At the beginning of each unit, we watch clips from the three main presidential candidates of the 2008 election (Obama, McCain, and Clinton) to see how the themes of the unit relate to the speeches we will read (also a good listening exercise and illustrates the important differences between listening to and reading a speech). So far, we've given two vocabulary quizzes and the students have written letters in response to Douglass' speech. We also did a successful roleplay activity in which we divided the classes into groups of 3-4 students that had to represent the views of Douglass, abolitionists, slaveowners and the slaves themselves. It was an interesting discussion and the students had good responses based on their roles. Tomorrow in my class we'll be having the 2nd vocabulary quiz, looking at a powerpoint about images related to the civil rights movement and finishing MLK's "I have a Dream." Thursday we'll be watching MLK's speech, probably on Youtube (which makes me nervous because of technical difficulties in loading the video, but I don't know of a better source--any ideas?) and then doing a fun listening activity with Bob Dylan's song "Blowin in the Wind."
The midterm for the content class is to pretend they are speech writers for Obama and he needs them to write a speech detailing the challenges that African Americans have faced and overcome in history, and who paved the way for him to run for President. We hope they'll be creative and support their ideas with information from class as well as independent research. They are supposed to write about 900-1000 words and use 10 new vocabulary words. They are also required to work with a partner to brainstorm their ideas and edit their speeches. The partner will have to fill out a peer review sheet about the strengths and weaknesses of the speech. The final part of the assignment is delivering the partner's speech to the class (since the writer is just a speech-writer, the partner will pretend to be Obama). The midterm will be assigned next week and is due on October 30th, so we'll see how it goes!
So Hanna and I each teach two sections of the English class and two sections of the Content class this semester, for approximately 8 hours a week; planning and grading takes up a lot of time though. The average number of students in our class is about 20 (we each have about 80 students), but the enrollment varies significantly based on the class's time. For instance, my 40-minute content class that meets on T/TH only has 7 students, but my 80-minute content class that meets on Wed. has 26! It's the same course, and teacher, but it seems like the T/TH class is a more popular class time. This disparity is frustrating though, since the same lesson plan has a drastically different outcome. Also, the 7 person class clearly has many more opportunities to practice their English than the 26 person group. My English classes are much more even, 15 and 18 students each, though Hanna has a 6-person class and a 20-something person English class. It's unclear why there are these differences, but hopefully next semester the sizes can be more even since it would be easier for us and more beneficial to the students.
In general, the undergraduate classes are fun and enjoyable. It's certainly a change though to be in front of the classroom after having been a student for my entire life. When students give their issue presentations in English and I sit down to take notes, I have to remind myself to go back up and lead class once they finish, that I can't just sit for the rest of the period and listen to someone else speak. The students are very sweet and friendly--they call me Alexa, not Teacher or Ms. Verme--and I've been impressed with their English for the most part. Of course some classes and days are better than others and I find that there are many factors that can make a class seem great or terrible that day: I might be having a bad day, the students might be having a bad day or be tired, the lesson plan might not work as planned, there might be technical difficulties, etc. As a result, I try not to read into the more tedious classes too much, especially since I'm just starting to teach and still feel like I have an exponential learning curve.
The amount of authority I seem to have in a classroom interests me though. The students all seem to respect me, though I am really only two years older than them (I'm not sure how many of them realize that, though they do know that I just graduated from college). They do their homework and study for the quizzes I assign and follow my instructions for classroom activities. Again, it's odd for me to be in front of the classroom though, calling on students randomly, taking attendance, constantly writing on the board, answering questions, saying "See you Thursday!" and hearing a chorus of voices respond "See you!"
One of the biggest challenges is getting the students to participate. In general, my students are very quiet and reluctant to speak up in class, even if I'm asking a rather simple question (not about their opinion, more about facts). Unlike the American school system, in China teachers does not emphasize creativity and peer based discussion; I assume my students are not very used to being called on to speak in class. Add the fact that English is their second language and even fewer want to speak. Plus, no one wants to be wrong and lose face, either in front of me or their classmates, so I get a lot of whispering and murmuring when I ask a question but few hands and clear answers. Sometimes I have to say "I hear the right answer, say it louder." Or, "I think you're right, I just can't hear you," which is usually the case. Other times, I just call on students after several seconds have passed without a response. Often, I've been really impressed by their answers--which can make it even more frustrating that they don't volunteer the information themselves, since their ideas are good. I have to remind myself that I was more often than not that type of student though, usually preferring to listen than speak up myself, and I try to cut them some slack. Now I finally understand though why teachers always wanted us to have lively discussions--it's so hard to stand up there and not have anyone respond to questions!
At times, students have asked me some interesting questions though. Three stand out in particular. After reading Douglass' "What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?" speech, a student who I like a lot asked "but why didn't Douglass tell the slaves how to escape?" His question made me realize that I had to make it clear who exactly was able to listen to Douglass' speech (I had assumed they would realize slaves were clearly not in the audience) and it also prompted an interesting discussion about the power of technology and how that has changed the nature of speeches (i.e. when Douglass gave his speech, only those present were able to listen to his words, but now we have been able to watch and listen to Obama's DNC speech a month later and across the world). Another student, in my 26 person class, asked me whether, as a native person from Brooklyn, an area with a lot of black people, racism still existed in the United States. I said yes, despite everyone being equal by law, discrimination still existed in many areas in society around the country. Unfortunately I didn't have much time to go on a tangent and explain further, but we talked for several minutes about peoples' behaviors vs. the law and undercurrents of racism in society. The last question that stood out came after a presentation about abortion on Thursday. A student asked the presenters (a rare occurrence, even though I ask if there are any questions at the end of each presentation) if the United States punishes women who have accidental abortions. The presenter promptly deferred to me, their "dear teacher." It was a good "teachable moment" when I was able to clarify miscarriage and abortion and explain the legal differences. These questions often feel a bit overwhelming at the time, because they're important and I'm on the spot and all eyes are on me, but its certainly inspiring when my students ask such thoughtful questions.
Plagiarism is another challenge. We haven't assigned much writing yet, though the first day of class Hanna and I both explained that we take plagiarism very seriously and if they are caught they will fail the assignment and be reported to the Academic Dean of the College. We are going to review citing guidelines before we hand out the midterm. It has been a bit of an issue with the presentations though, which is even harder to spot. Often students seem to recite their presentations, speaking in perfect English sentences. I can assume that a teacher at some point advised them that memorizing a speech is more professional than occassionally looking at notecards; I'm sure they also feel more in control if they memorize full sentences and deliver them to the class. It's fairly easy to tell what's been copied from a website though--what sounds too good or uses too complex words--but difficult to know what to do about it. I naively didn't think that the 5 minute presentations would pose such problems with plagiarism. As a result, I didn't go over many guidelines before they began, other than that they should give me their sources (which are often as general as www.johnmccain.com; one student even just gave me www.google.com as his source!). So, for instance, two girls emailed me their presentation the night before it was due and I realized quickly that they had just copied entire sentences from the websites. When I replied and said they should re-write the presentation because it wasn't in their own words (in a nicer way than that), one of the girls came to my office hours the next day and apologized, saying she thought that if she told me where it was from, she could copy the text. Only then did I realize how serious the copying problem may be with all or most of the presentations, but since most students did not email me their presentations in advance and I didn't ask them to, it's a little late to dock them points. I think I'll try to handle the situation by giving overall comments and feedback to both classes once the presentations are finished (this Thursday). Hopefully I can pre-empt this situation in the future; again, more experience teaching will be helpful.
Attendance is a final difficulty we're facing. In our syllabus Hanna and I wrote what we thought was a strict and clear attendance policy--students were supposed to attend class unless they had a serious illness or a family emergency, when they had to email us at least 2 hours before class. Three of these absences or any unexcused absences would lower their grade by five points. Of course, we've gotten many emails from "sick" students in the past few weeks. Since everyone has a different standard of what constitutes "sickness" (a lot of these students seem to have had colds, if they were sick at all, which does not count in my book!), it's hard to know what's a legitimate reason and what's not. Hanna had a student email her early on saying her face was swollen and she couldnt' come to class, which seemed pretty silly at the time, but the following class Hanna saw her and her face really was swollen from an allergy. I don't want to question everything my students write, but there have been too many sick students to believe everyone. For this semester I think I'll just have to figure out the grades at the end of the semester and base most of the attendance on how hard they worked when they were in class (if they had an unexcused absence but worked hard the rest of the time vs. sending me an email but never speaking up in class). In the future, I think we'll have to make participation and attendance a much larger part of their grades--perhaps 30-35%--to make it clear that it is a priority for us.
Overall though, I'm enjoying my classes and getting to know my students. I hope that in the future I can become friends with some of them, though I'm trying to maintain pretty strict boundaries now (no cell phone numbers, only my Lingnan email address, etc). The faculty and staff classes are also good, but I don't spend as much time planning the lessons and don't have as much invested in the material. The people in the classes generally are motivated and speak quite good English, so we plan vocabulary activities and try to focus on improving fluency and accuracy. It would be nice to stay in touch with some of those students after the semester ends as well; many of them are friendly and would be great to get to know better outside of class.
Whew! I'm sure I'll add more teaching stories soon, but, as I start my fifth week, there's an overview of what my job is like--at least this semester.
Zaijian!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Hello,
This was a great description of how you and Hanna are preparing your assignments and class interactions. Thanks for the window to your work. Joseph
Post a Comment