Monday, March 16, 2009

Student's Impressions of the US and China

Dajia Hao!

Hope everyone is having a great weekend. If you've been following the blog, now you know some of the background of the Zhuhai situation as well as the basic structure of the American culture course we're teaching this semester. Now we can get onto more interesting topics, like what the students have been writing as their impressions of America, Americans and China. I've typed up a bunch of my students responses, verbatim (misspelled words included) to different prompts. Some are creative, some disturbing, some funny and all interesting and honest. I don't have the energy right now to post all of my thoughts as well, but I'll do another update on the course in a few weeks with more details.

Happy reading, and feel free to comment--I'd love to know your reactions.

1. A free association activity where they listed the first words they thought of in response to a variety of phrases, like American food, American cities, Hollywood, etc. Here were some of the most common or most interesting ones.

Words: creative, multicultural, open, melting pot, freedom, fashionable, immigrant, junk food, opportunity, fast-paced, prosperity, romantic, ambitious, independence, practical, over-consumption, diverse, self-reliant, rich, racial discrimination, powerful, dynamic, commercial, democracy, tolerance, honestly, individualism, punctuality


2. Write a paragraph about what it means to be an American or what life is like for an American.

“Unlike people in china, Americans can say whatever they think and feel about their present president and government, even vote to replace him if he falls down on the job.”

“First being an American means freedom to me. America is the country of immigrants, which makes tolerance be an important factor of American culture. Different concepts, beliefs, habits and traditions are all accepted. Everyone can choose the lives they lead. Second, being an American means having equal opportunity to succeed. Origin, color, race, or anything else is by no means the key to success. Instead it is effort and determination that matters. It seems that as long as you never give up, reward will follow. Unfortunately, however, being an American can be as a consequence of leading an intense live in a country full of competition. In my imagination, chances are that American also means dangerous in the Middle East. Thanks to foreign policy and the war, American has become the target of some terrorists recently.”

“As long as you work hard, a comfortable life can be guaranteed, no worry of competing with 1.3 billion people around you. Being an American also means that you can have as much junk food as you like.”

"Americans are quite ok with doing things all together and at the same time feel comfortable of doing things by oneself and need a lot of privacy. Americans don't like to tell other people about their age, their body weight, their salaries, their family affairs and also maybe some other personal stuff."

"I have an interest in America. She has a very short history, but now is the most powerful country of the world. She is rich and developed very well. But at back, America also have some problems. For example, the discrimination and aggression. In America, racial discrimination in everywhere, whites live a more easeful life than the others, even though Obama has been the president. America also aggressive. As the most powerful country she should take the responsibility to keep the world peaceful. However, she has made many wars, lead to many countrys turbulent. A lot of people lose their families and homeless. Hope that one day this situation could be changed. As my thought, American are living a comfortable life. They get to university very easy, get job more easy, have much time to take a holiday, and received well welfare from government. Most of American have a good sense of humor, they confidence, extroverted, and good at creation. Make friends with them may easy and interesting."

“The vast difference between Chinese and Americans can also be reflected in the education systems. American focus more on the thinking process, while students in China always fight for the final score.”

“An American family usually have their own independent house and have more than 2 children and cars. At weekend, they goes out together for a family travel or shops in the super makets like warl-mart where actually they can find anything they need. Because frequently eat food like what’s in the Macdonald, you have a fat figure easily….anyone may carry a gun to protect themselves which I consider in fact a very dangerous kind of freedom. Though a country emphasized individualism, people of it is likely to be a responsible citizen and patriotic and always ready to fight for their nation, or more precisely, for the values of their country.

“The concept of utilitarianism and efficiency which has been handed down from ancestors for ages is displayed by fast food for lunch inventions of practical utilities and the high-speed and stressful pace of life. However, the efficiency at work may easily give rise to the lack of love and care for the family, making the divorcing rate uproaring.”

‘Usually when somebody mentions an American, I will think of a young white lady in very expensive clothes shopping in a busy street. Yes, that’s an image shown in the movie “Sex and the City” so I think if you to be an American, your life will be very busy, busy making money, busy shopping, busy with colorful night life, and you will so rich that you can afford a lot of expensive things such as LV bags, BMW cards, grand house and so on. “

“There’s also a strange question: why most common people in the USA are so huge while almost all stars there are too skinny? Do they have quite different value of beauty?”

“To be an American, he should own at least one car, rent a well-decorated apartment, do a high-pay job and have some bonds and stocks. He likes to read newspaper when having breakfast and then go to work by car. His evening is usually wonderful: dancing and drinking with friends in bar or watching football and basketball matches till midnight. He can go to traveling or picnic with his family occasionally for he can always get holidays from his job.”

"Just imagine you must get up early so that you commute to work on time, then you have your breakfast--a coffee and a sandwich as soon as possible. To your pity, you come to work late because of the New York traffic jam. Your boss warns you that if you can't finish your quota, you will be in danger of unemployment, so you devote yourself into work to make a living. That's my impression of American white collar's stressful and hectic lives."

“The other point is that American consider people as in equal situation. What impress me most is that people just call each other with their first name, while in China, there are a lot of regulations for different relatives, or for boss or someone else.”

“Americans are used to being informal, most likely they are always in a great hurry. People of all ages may prefer to be called by their first name. Americans like making ‘small talk’ with various topics. Because they think that ‘honesty is the best policy’ they are very direct to do things”

“Nowadays to be an American needs a brave heart, struggling with terrorism, financial crisis, environment pollution. And the new inherit their ancestors explorer spirit. They vote Obama to lead Americans to face an epic challenge and a nation in a world of hurt. It was just as much a strikingly symbolic moment in the evolution of the nation’s frought racial history a breakthrough that would have seemed unthinkable just two years ago. As the globe could see, Americans have no limits to go beyond. Impossible is nothing.”

“In all, Americans’ life are much harder than Chineses’ because they have to face their own life with their own choice the whole life while in china almost every child refers to parents and teachers before 18, taking every step”

“As the saying goes, one shoulders his responsibilities while he enjoys his rights. Americans should also be responsible. Because of their strong position, Americans feel obliged to devote themselves to global affairs including booming global economy, spreading modern culture and negotiating for peace.”

“American’s like to use ‘tomorrow’s money’ thus credict cards play an important role. In contrary, Chinese tend to spend their savings to consume.”

“Americans are very lively and creative. They always full of passion and have numerous incredible ideas to make their lifes more colourful and convenient. They never just think about it but put it into practice. That’s the reason why so many technologies applied widespread all over the world are mainly created by Americans. They may live a busy going life because there’re so many advanced devices to help them make full use of every minute. Many work is done by machine. Life is easier but more complicated. People are faced with too many choices. Americans have more leisure time to have entertainment. However, wonderful devices eat up their time, making them tired rather than relaxed. People rely on machines so heavily that without them they don’t know how to live.”

“I think American’s life is fantasy, colourful and exciting. American’s household is large. It is common that a family consists of parents, many children and even some pet…then speaking of food, American often eat pot roast of chicken, potatoes, salad, and vegetables went with the main course, with pie or cake for dessert. Primarily Americans food include meet so it often rich of fat and oil. In addition with the development of fast food, problem of fat has become more and more serious in American. There’s been a big change in American food. Because both parents are away from home for long hours, nobody is whipping up those delicious meals in the kitchen. Americans have a quantity of entertainment. American family often go outside at vacation. In the summer they canoe on the river and taking bicycle rides. In the winter, they ski and skate. Furthermore, after sunset they may patronize restaurants, see the film or watch opera. Especially at Christmas day family member will exchange presents with each other. At allhallowmas, children will make a pumpkin lamp to play. But danger live around American’s life. I think crime rate at America is high. Mass of adult and teenages are addicted to take drug. Murders often occur at America. Even at school, the cases of shooting often occur. There is a big change at workplace at America. More and more mothers are in the workforce. Working at America is tired. You often leave homes at dawn and don’t return until dark and you only have a shot break at noon for lunch. Luckily their labor is paid off. American often have large income and wages to support their comfortable live. As an old saying goes: if you like someone, you can let them to America, but if you hate someone, you can let him to America too.”

“First I come to brainstorm: new Yorker, American Idol, racial-melted pot with different color and different belief. High education level of average people. “All are free all are equal all deserve a chance to pursue their full measure of happiness”-Obama inauguration. But what American life would be? Actually as a student raised in a conservative or to be said exam oriented education environment I just cannot fancy the real, specific life of American with an exception to its Hollywood movie, in which life of the 200-year history country may depict some of the common philosophy of the citizen of the USA. Be oneself, have one own dream regardless of others’ views, though never have I understood why there are still so many disbeliefs others’ but voices loudly American tolerate from different minds. But still, there are somethings that’s really impressive. President of a country would be greatly impeached and fiercely criticized, received skeptism and even be painted in a funny picture. Pause are reflect, conservation, led to Chinese failure in history, while an open land’s science and technology soar to a unparalled level, power being immensely improved. And this kind of speech freedom from my view, serves as a strongest power promoting the constitution, carrying on the words of the founders, since 1787. To cover all above, American is one who do what he/she thinks are right. Right for oneself, with invisible hand, contributes to the whole. “

“Hello I am Anne a wife and mother. Seven o’clock my clock rings on times so that I must get up to cook my small family breakfast some milk and some bread and eggs. Half an hour later my husband will call me just like ‘where is my blue tie’ oh dear. My socks where are they’ my little son will start his nauty day. After the ‘war’ my husband goes to work by car. He is an engineer in a conduction company. I have to drive my son to the kindergarten. Nine o’clock I appears in my workplace in a hurry. By the way I’m an accountor of a small company. The work is busy and tired. Five o’clock I leave to pick up my son and be busy with the supper. We are traditional family, we will watch tv at night and talk with them about something happen today. In holiday we will go out for fun. I like my life busy, normal but full of love and fun.”

“In my opinion the American life is colorful. The Americans are always borned in a family with many sisters and brothers. Unlike china where people cant have more than one child. So being a child in America will not feel lonely and can grow to be an independent man. Then the Americans go to school. The school is much more free and easy than that in china, full of practices and keep away from too many exams and stress. They can grow to be a man with creative mind. After high school, American can go to many excellent universities like Harvard and Yale, where they can well develop their skill to live in the real society. Then they grow up, find a job, maybe makes them very busy, fall into love freely and have a family. I always dreams of the wonderful American life like this: a big garden, swimming pole, lovely children running and laughing on the grass. Maybe the real American life is far from this easy life but the free and creativity is what most Chinese looking for their whole life.”

“it is hard to show every aspect of American and their lives so I want to use a special way to reflect some parts of it. Suspecting I’m an American undergraduate, I’d like to show you my daily life. Even though I’m an undergraduate, I live with my family. There are five members in my family, my parents, my brother, I and a cute puppy. Its hard to find a family without a pet or just have one child in America. It is exactly a week since our family moved in the house. Its’ the second move in this year and you will find most Americans have got used to this. There are two main bedroom in the house because my parents like to have their own rooms. It doesn’t mean the relationship of my parents isn’t good, but its’ a popular way in recent America. I’m a little fat because I like sweet and fried food like many Americans do and I can’t live without cheese and butter. But I like sports. I often play golf, bowling and volleyball. At weedens there are many people in the gymnasium. I have a boyfriend and we often dine out, but usually we pay for each other. You may think its unbelievable but it’s the manner in America. My parents never interfere in what I’m doing and they’d like to join the party hold in our house by me. My neighbor is a wealth man who has just divorced. Because of this, he expensed a great deal of money. He and my father often travel together on vacation. You should know that almost every worker in American has a more than two week vacation. Sometimes we use this chance to have a four-day camping or do repairs by ourselves. Most American are open minded and independent. And we also think highly of profit and ability. Maybe you can learn something about American life by reading this paragraph but they are just the tip of the iceberg.”

“from my childhood to my senior school the education I received told me: America is imperialist and it is aggressive. In our history book, no matter eight-country alliance invaded China in 19c or resist America to assist North Korea in 1951 America was described as enemy. To tell you the truth, when terrorist attacked world trade centre on 11th in September. I’m sorry for that most Chinese are happy. Yes, I apologize for our mood which is avenging. But, this is true, I still remember my classmates shouts that America serves its right loudly. I beg your pardon. After all, now, I know from humane mood although you are not ordinary country like Russia or Pakistan, we should commiserate, be pity of that, because we are human in one earth, we all love peace and harmony, we all treasure friendship, we all resist war. There are many differences in race, religion, culture, history, value between China and other countries. However, we should treasure the same thing we both have: humanity. Okay, after summarise the impression of America fro my history book and my surroundings, I’d like to share my views on relationship between Chinese and American. In fact, our impression on other countries is affected heavily by politics. Yes, my government told me, Russia is friend, Pakistan is alliance, western countries hate us because our development, Japan fears China for China’s progress…at the same time, newspaper, magazine, tv have the same tone. Who is friend, who is enemy, it is obvious. You can say: your government ave cheated you. But I don’t angry for its cheat. As we all know, every government in the world impose its value to its people. Just like German always resist China, France always critic China, so China can hate America although it maybe wrong. However, we, the common people, should have own attitude to different countries rather than controlled by media or politics. I think the best way for is: communicate. Yea, we need to contact with foreigners, to communicate our culture, our value, and to understand different values. Only by communication we can eliminate misunderstand and then establish real friendship beside profit reason. For example by watching NBA. Most young man in china become the fans to Kobe, James and other ball star by watching films, Tom Kluse, Wenslite become our ideal. By Olympic games, we love Philps as well as you. And then we found American are enthusiastic, energetic, frank and easy-going. They have dream they believe liberty, opportunity, democracy, human rights. America is a great country with legendary history, with top scientist, university, businessman and so on. So I am grateful for your course. This is a small step for us to get knowledge of America. I dream for that after several year, I can go to your country and tell them many thing about China. To promote our communication. Often a window for two sides. Only after we know each other, we understand mutual value and background of it, can we get along with each other. Thank you for reading. Welcome to China, welcome to Xian! You are doing a job which is great! Thank you!

“…In some countries eyes, to be an American means torture, assassination and terrorism. To be a torture, it is because the administration had its now attorney general draw up a memo justifying the use of torture against prisoners, male and female, no holds barred. To be an assassination, Americans assassinated the leaders of other nations at will, if they don’t like their policies. The administration calls it ‘regime change’, but it is outright murder, in violation of all international law. Actually many presidents of the United States were died of murder. At last, as a terrorism, the Americans have used massive weapons of destruction to kill about 20,000 -30,000 Iraqi civilians, mostly women and little children. Then what the hell does it mean to be an American? Nobody knows.”


3. Make a list of the impressions you think foreigners have about China, Chinese people or Chinese culture.

China: big, powerful, long history, vast territory, populous,
Chinese: intelligent, hardworking, diligent, kind-hearted, remarkable endurance, workaholic, cordial, Jews of Asia, united, hospitable, superstitious, narrow-minded, bookworm, lack personality, humble, careful, foolish, dirty, dull, independent, thrifty, modest, friendly, not creative, conservative, suffering, tolerance, discipline
Of Chinese people they might think of slightly short and thin compared to the western standard, not so much hugging and kissing, having been suffered a lot in the past, united, sometimes impolite, eager to get in touch with the world, ec
Society: closed, threatening, eager to get in touch with the world, tolerant except to Japan and France
History: glorious, rich, feudal, many inventions, humiliated, wars, kong fu, Confucius, Mencius, dragon, 4 inventions, calligraphy
Cities: shanghai, Beijing, Xian; some are large prosperous crowded while some are not well developed, pollution,
Countryside: peaceful, cheap labor force, farm
Food: rice dumpling, dumpling, noodles, delicious, chopsticks, round table
Music and art: ink and wash, Chinese jade, terracotta warriors, Peking Opera,
Government: powerful, huge, communist party, dictatorship, lack democracy
Families in the city: 2 adults, 1 child, 4-2-1 shape, scattered, respect your elders
Value: conservative, collectivism, family centered, consume latter
Economy: grow fast, internationalization, made in China, booming, world’s factory
Environment: severe pollution, abundant resources
Culture: collectivism, interpersonal relations, equality

Those who unfamiliar with china will consider Chinese people all live a poor life.Those who familiar with china know that there are different kinds of living standards with great wealth gap between the rich and the poor.

Chinese prefer to use the phrase ‘the waking of giant dragon’ to describe china’s economic development in recent years. Which however makes westerners feel concerned. In west culture, dragon is often connected with violence and disaster. But in china, it represents luck and creativity. As a result, china threatening theory or something like this kind which often show up in Western media are accepted by many ordinary people.”

They are capable of copy methods, especially in the industry.

3 comments:

goooooood girl said...

your blog is very good......

John Dwyer said...

I particularly enjoyed and was informed by the students comments.

Joseph said...

This is a great blog. Great to have the chance to see some of how the students view America and Americans. Thanks for typing all of this for us. Joseph